Apple Ordered To Pay $3.3 Million In Japanese Lawsuit Over Patent Violation

Apple Ordered To Pay $3.3 Million In Japanese Lawsuit Over Patent Violation

A district court in Tokyo, Japan, has ordered Apple to pay ¥330 million or $3.3 million in damages to Norihiko Saito, a Japanese inventor. The lawsuit is related to the click wheel system found on a number of past iPod models. The current iPod classic uses a similar click wheel system. Saito’s company had applied for a patent that covered this technology back in 1998. Apple adopted the technology for its music players in 2004.

An injunction request was filed by Saito with Tokyo Customs against Apple back in 2007, requesting that iPod imports into Japan be blocked as his patent was being infringed upon. This prompted settlement negotiations. However, three rounds of negotiations didn’t lead to a settlement. Saito then raised his damages claim to ¥10 billion or $101 million, the figure was based on iPod sales at that point in time. However, according to the Tokyo District Court, Apple’s infringement of Saito’s patent does not warrant such a hefty damages payout. Instead, it has directed the company to pay $3.3 million in damages to Norihiko Saito. The click wheel basically combines a circle touch sensor with a number of buttons which allows for easy use with just one hand. It can be used for selecting music as well as for scrolling and fast-forwarding.

  • Follow: Apple, ipod classic,
  • Apple Ordered To Pay $3.3 Million In Japanese Lawsuit Over Patent Violation original content from Ubergizmo.

        



    Apple hit with $3 million damages in Japanese iPod click wheel dispute

    Image

    Apple is no stranger to lawsuits targeting the iPhone and iPad, but over in Japan, it’s the company’s older iPod design that has landed it in hot water. Kyodo News reports that the Tokyo District Court ordered Apple to pay ¥300 million ($3.3 million) to Japanese inventor Norihiko Saito for infringing on a patent covering the touch-sensitive click wheel used in the iPod Classic and older models of its iconic music player. Saito’s damages come more than five years after he filed the patent lawsuit, during which time he demanded damages of ¥10 billion ($101 million), based partly on the number of iPods Apple had sold during that period. Fortunately for Apple, the final figure was substantially less than Saito’s demand and it’ll only have to sell a few more iPhones to cover the cost.

    Filed under: ,

    Comments

    Via: Dow Jones

    Source: Kyodo News

    Say Goodbye to the iPod Classic

    Say Goodbye to the iPod Classic

    2013 will be known as the year the iPod classic died.

        



    Budget iPhone Could Be A Frankenstein Phone Borrowing From iPhone 5, iPod Touch [Rumor]

     Budget iPhone Could Be A Frankenstein Phone Borrowing From iPhone 5, iPod Touch [Rumor]

    The rumors for Apple’s cheaper iPhone have been all over the place as some reports say it exists, while others say Apple wouldn’t offer a cheaper iPhone at all. Today’s news, once again, claims a cheaper iPhone does exist, and in fact goes into detail on what exactly the cheaper iPhone will look like.

    The report published today comes from iLounge who claims they have information in regards to how the cheaper iPhone may look like whenever Apple decides to announce it to the world. The cheaper iPhone is said to be a combination of a number of mobile iOS devices as it’ll have the iPhone 5′s front, the bottom of the fifth-generation of iPod touch, and the overall form of the iPod classic.

    This Frankenstein iPhone will adopt a number of features from the iOS devices its taking influence from as its back will have more of a curve than recent iPhones, similar to the iPod classic’s curve, and even though its front will resemble an iPhone 5, its screen will slightly jut out, similar to how it does with the iPod touch.

    By Ubergizmo. Related articles: 2013 iPhones To See In-Cell Touch (Rumor), Apple Rumored To Be Working On An “iPhone Math” ,

    Dude recreates first-gen iPod in-browser, won’t put 1,000 songs in your pocket

    Dude recreates firstgen iPod in the browser, won't put 1,000 songs in your pocket

    Here’s a bit of web fun to liven up your weekend: a digital artist by the name of Pritesh Desai has recreated a fully functional first-generation iPod that you can play directly in your browser. In remembrance of Steve Jobs, Desai built the faux iPod using HTML5, CSS3, and a touch of jQuery. You can drag the click wheel around just like with the real deal, change the volume, hit play / pause and even skip tracks. Especially nice is the addition of Extras like the Clock and the Calendar. Unfortunately, you won’t be able to play any of your own tunes, but Desai had compiled a list of Creative Commons songs, so you can see how the player works. The next step is for someone to fill this up with hits of the early aughts (“Last Nite” by The Strokes, perhaps?) so you can truly travel back in time to the heydays of Windows XP and the Enron scandal.

    Filed under:

    Dude recreates first-gen iPod in-browser, won’t put 1,000 songs in your pocket originally appeared on Engadget on Fri, 05 Oct 2012 15:27:00 EDT. Please see our terms for use of feeds.

    Permalink Gizmodo  |  sourceInventika Solutions (1), (2)  | Email this | Comments

    Classic iPod in Your Browser: The Best Way to Waste Your Friday [IPod]

    The iPod Classic might have one foot in the grave, but it still lives. On your computer. A clever designer made this fully playable iPod for your browser. And it really works, just like your old mp3 player. How awesome is that? More »

    Apple EarPods review: A $29 revolution in earbuds or another set for the recycling bin?

    DNP Apple EarPods review A $29 revolution in earbuds or another set for the recycling bin

    Whether you think they’re infamous or merely a signature piece of Apple design, there’s no doubt most of us have been exposed the company’s iconic white earbuds. Along with the latest batch of iPods and the iPhone 5, Apple announced the replacement for those dreaded earphones, a pair of ‘buds called the EarPods. Given that these are bundled with new iDevices (also sold as a standalone for $29), it’s hard not to think that the folks at Cupertino are drinking some sort of spiked Kool-Aid, claiming these rival headphones that cost hundreds more. While reviewing the likes of the iPhone 5, we also gave the EarPods a listen to find out whether or not they’re just an over-engineered set of ‘buds. You’ll find our detailed verdict after the break.

    Continue reading Apple EarPods review: A $29 revolution in earbuds or another set for the recycling bin?

    Filed under: ,

    Apple EarPods review: A $29 revolution in earbuds or another set for the recycling bin? originally appeared on Engadget on Tue, 18 Sep 2012 21:00:00 EDT. Please see our terms for use of feeds.

    Permalink   |   | Email this | Comments

    iPod classic lives to play another day

    The more things change, the more they stay the same — for our old pal the iPod Classic, at least. Sure Apple went and revamped the rest of its music playing brethren, but the HDD stalwart is, as its name implies, staying true to its roots. Death rumors aside, the high-capacity player is sitting pretty over in Apple’s online store. Those who need a shot of 160GB nostalgia can still pick one up for $250.

    Filed under: ,

    iPod classic lives to play another day originally appeared on Engadget on Wed, 12 Sep 2012 16:49:00 EDT. Please see our terms for use of feeds.

    Permalink   |  sourceApple  | Email this | Comments