There appears to be a very good reason why the iPhone 4’s new FaceTime video-calling app only work on Wi-Fi: On a cellular network, it sucks.
Mike Prospero of Laptop Magazine used the HTC EVO to turn a 3G (not 4G) connection into a Wi-Fi hotspot, tricking the iPhone into making a FaceTime call over the cellular network. The second iPhone was on regular Wi-Fi. The result, as you’ll see if you check the non-embeddable video that accompanies the post, is painful. If you have ever had a bad, stuttering Skype call you’ll know what to expect: audio breaks up, and calling the choppy images “video” is charitable to say the least.
“Audio came through only in patches, and video was like a slideshow at best,” says Prospero. Poor video performance over 3G isn’t limited to FaceTime, either. Tests of Qik and Fring show similar problems. Clearly, cellular networks aren’t up to the task just yet.
So what of FaceTime’s future? I have a feeling that the iPod Touch will be getting an iPhone 4-style makeover at the usual September iPod event this year, and will incorporate FaceTime. Thanks to the Wi-Fi limitations, this feature will be at parity with the iPhone. And then, surely, it will come to the iPad, too.
You know how everyone is on Skype and FaceBook because everybody else is on Skype and FaceBook? The same thing will happen for iOS devices as soon as people get a little bit of FaceTime. When the cellular networks finally catch up, they’ll realize that they have become nothing but dumb pipes for shifting data.
We Use iPhone 4’s FaceTime over 3G (Sorta) [Laptop Mag]
See Also:
- Video: iPhone 4 Looks Gorgeous, But FaceTime Face Plants
- Surprise: Wi-Fi Only FaceTime Doesn't Use Cellular Minutes …
- Apple Unveils High-Resolution, Videoconferencing iPhone 4
- Showdown: iPhone 4 vs. HTC Evo 4G
Screen capture from Laptop Mag’s Video